diff --git a/scripts/ui/question_player.gd b/scripts/ui/question_player.gd
index e23bb4d..7782d57 100644
--- a/scripts/ui/question_player.gd
+++ b/scripts/ui/question_player.gd
@@ -2968,17 +2968,11 @@ func _set_choice_button_text(index: int, choice: Dictionary) -> void:
 	choice_buttons[index].custom_minimum_size = Vector2(0, 54)
 	_set_choice_percent_label(index, "")
 	_set_choice_top_label(index, "")
-	if locked_wrong_choice_ids.has(choice_id):
+	if locked_wrong_choice_ids.has(choice_id) or _should_show_correct_choice_percentage(choice_id):
 		var percentage := _get_choice_selection_percentage(choice_id)
 		if percentage >= 0:
 			_set_choice_percent_label(index, "%d%%" % percentage)
-		choice_buttons[index].text = choice_text
-	elif _should_show_correct_choice_percentage(choice_id):
-		var correct_percentage := _get_choice_selection_percentage(choice_id)
-		if correct_percentage >= 0:
-			_set_choice_percent_label(index, "%d%%" % correct_percentage)
-		choice_buttons[index].text = choice_text
-	elif eliminated.has(choice_id):
+	if eliminated.has(choice_id):
 		choice_buttons[index].text = ""
 		_set_choice_top_label(index, "[s]%s[/s]" % _escape_bbcode(choice_text))
 	else:
diff --git a/tests/post_answer_review_test.gd b/tests/post_answer_review_test.gd
index 5b02a2a..4ec4139 100644
--- a/tests/post_answer_review_test.gd
+++ b/tests/post_answer_review_test.gd
@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ func _initialize() -> void:
 	_test_correct_feedback_does_not_auto_advance()
 	_test_correct_review_locks_answer_interactions()
 	_test_eliminated_choice_uses_rich_text_strikeout()
+	_test_eliminated_choice_that_is_also_locked_wrong_still_strikes_through()
 	_test_explanation_highlighting_has_no_status_heading()
 	_test_collapsed_followup_review_expands()
 	_test_review_content_normalization()
@@ -143,6 +144,27 @@ func _test_eliminated_choice_uses_rich_text_strikeout() -> void:
 	player.free()
 
 
+func _test_eliminated_choice_that_is_also_locked_wrong_still_strikes_through() -> void:
+	var player = load("res://scripts/ui/question_player.gd").new()
+	player.choice_buttons.append(Button.new())
+	player.choice_percent_labels.append(Label.new())
+	var strike_label := RichTextLabel.new()
+	strike_label.bbcode_enabled = true
+	player.choice_top_labels.append(strike_label)
+	player.choice_followup_panels.append(PanelContainer.new())
+	player.eliminated = ["A"]
+	player.locked_wrong_choice_ids = ["A"]
+	player.presented_choices = [{"id": "A", "text": "Observation only"}]
+	player._set_choice_button_text(0, player.presented_choices[0])
+	_assert(strike_label.text == "[s]Observation only[/s]", "a choice that's both eliminated and locked-wrong should still strike through")
+	_assert(player.choice_buttons[0].text == "", "the struck-through choice's button text should stay cleared")
+	player.choice_buttons[0].free()
+	player.choice_percent_labels[0].free()
+	strike_label.free()
+	player.choice_followup_panels[0].free()
+	player.free()
+
+
 func _test_explanation_highlighting_has_no_status_heading() -> void:
 	var player = load("res://scripts/ui/question_player.gd").new()
 	player.explanation_label = RichTextLabel.new()